Apple Inc. v. Psystar Corp.

Summarized by:

  • Court: Intellectual Property Archives
  • Area(s) of Law: Copyright
  • Date Filed: 09-28-2011
  • Case #: 10-15113
  • Judge(s)/Court Below: Schroeder
  • Full Text Opinion

COPYRIGHT; MISUSE (It is not misuse when a copyright holder limits the right to use their work.)

Apple Inc. (“Apple”) created Mac OS X software for Apple computers.  Psystar Corp. (“Psystar”) made computers and sold them with Mac OS X software loaded onto them.  Apple sued Psystar alleging copyright infringement of its Mac OS X software because Apple specifically limited the use of its Mac OS X software to Apple Computers.  The district court found that Apple had a valid copyright in the Mac OS X software and that Psystar had infringed Apple’s copyright by putting the Mac OS X software on Psystar’s computers that it sold.  Psystar appealed the district court’s decision and argued that Apple’s limitation on the copyright of Mac OS X software was a misuse of its copyright because the Apple was trying to control the Mac OS X software after it was sold.  Psystar argues that because it purchased retail versions of Mac OS X software, Apple’s copyright shouldn’t control where they put the software after they purchase it.  However, the Court of Appeals held that Apple was not misusing its license by placing a condition on the use of their software because other competitor’s can still create their own operating systems.  The Court of Appeals AFFIRMED judgment in favor of Apple.

Advanced Search

Back to Top