- 1998-2011
- M. Lee Pelton
- 1997-1998
- Bryan Johnston (interim)
- 1980-1997
- Jerry E. Hudson
- 1973-1980
- Robert Lisensky
- 1972-1973
- James H. Corson
- 1969-1972
- Roger J. Fritz
- 1942-1969
- G. Herbert Smith
- 1941-1942
- Carl Sumner Knopf
- 1934-1941
- Bruce Richard Baxter,
- 1915-1934
- Carl Gregg Doney
- 1914-1915
- George Henry Alden (interim)
- 1908-1914
- Fletcher Homan
- 1902-1908
- John Hamline Coleman
- 1893-1902
- Willis Chatman Hawley
- 1891-1893
- George Whitaker
- 1880-1891
- Thomas Van Scoy
- 1879-1880
- Charles E. Lambert
- 1870-1879
- Thomas Milton Gatch
- 1868-1870
- Nelson Rounds
- 1867-1868
- Luther T. Woodward (interim)
- 1865-1867
- Joseph Henry Wythe
- 1865
- Leonard J. Powell (interim)
- 1860-1865
- Thomas Milton Gatch
- 1853-1860
- Francis S. Hoyt